Home » commentary » Debunking the Debunkers

Debunking the Debunkers


[Ed. note – A group of  scientists and academics have teamed up with the proprietor of a website called “Metabunk.org” in an attempt to disprove the naked truth that there is an ongoing program of geoengineering taking place in the skies above our heads.

The group–consisting of Christine Shearer, Mick West, Ken Caldeira, and Steven J. Davis–has published a  paper wherein the writers attempt to “scientifically evaluate the claims” that massive quantities of harmful particulates are being sprayed into the air, concluding, of course, that no such thing is taking place.

Dane Wigington of Geoengineering Watch has posted a lengthy refutation in which he criticizes their study on a number of points, deeming it “so full of omissions and completely skewed information that it is difficult to find a starting point with setting the record straight.” I’ll post a link to Wigington’s article below.

As to the four co-authors of the paper, Caldeira is a climate scientist with the Carnegie Institution for Science; Davis a professor at the University of California, Irvine; Shearer a climate researcher at CoalSwarm; while West, seemingly the odd-man in this non-string quartet, maintains Metabunk, a site dedicated to “honest, polite, scientific investigating and debunking.”

In addition to branding chemtrails a “conpspiracy theory,” Metabunk also asserts that World Trade Center Building 7 collapsed neatly into its own footprint due to fire, rather than controlled demolition.

The paper on geoengineering is entitled “Quantifying Expert Consensus Against the Existence of a Secret, Large-Scale Atmospheric Spraying Program.” You can go here to read a summary of it, here to access the full document, here to view a report on the study posted at the Weather Channel (includes a video of Davis using the loaded word “conspiracy” three times in under four minutes), and here to visit Shearer’s Twitter page which, last time I checked, included several tweets crowing about the great scientific achievement study represents.

Among the scholarly conclusions are that “a small but vocal group of people have been advocating” the existence of a spraying program, and that such wild claims may “lead the broader public to be confused or uncertain about the validity of the claims and data.” Also offered is the observation that “social scientists have noted parallels between belief in claims of a secret, large-scale atmospheric spraying program (SLAP) and growing public distrust of elites and social institutions.”

Perhaps the “social scientists” have it at least partially right–there is distrust of the “elites,” most assuredly so. But in terms of offering an explanation for “belief in claims of a secret, large-scale atmospheric spraying program,” that’s only one-third of the equation. The other two-thirds are that, a) elites, i.e. the richest one percent of the population, are not exactly angels, in many cases are guilty of a wide variety of sins, including advocating wars on false pretexts in which millions have died–and that it’s perfectly natural to distrust such people, and that b) the “large-scale atmospheric spraying program” is in fact happening. (Unless, of course, your lying eyes are deceiving you along with the media owned by the elites.)

It’s possible the whole thing could end up being decided in a court case. The Legal Alliance to Stop Geoengineering is expected to file a lawsuit over the matter, alleging violations of the Federal Clean Water Act and the Federal Safe Drinking Water Act, sometime later this year. Alleged “violators,” including Defense Secretary Ashton Carter, have been served with a 60-day notice of intent at any rate–and it could be that the recently-published study is, perhaps in part, an exercise in lining up “expert” testimony for the defendants should the case make it to trial.

At any rate, below is an excerpt from Wigington’s thesis. You can go here to access the full article.

The power structure’s propaganda machine has been put into high gear in a last ditch desperate attempt to hide the ongoing geoengineering planetary omnicide till the last possible moment. When the climate engineering crimes are fully exposed to populations around the globe (once and for all), a complete overturning of our paradigm will commence and those in power know it. The ongoing weather warfare that has been carried out for over 70 years has equally and irreparably harmed every person on the planet along with the entire web of life

The power structure and the criminals who serve them are completely committed to hiding the geoengineering/solar radiation management/climate intervention programs from the public for as long as possible. The effort to bring the climate engineering insanity to light is gaining ground rapidly. This has caused the global controllers to push back with a pathetic piece of total propaganda that does not in any objective way, shape, or form, address the mountain of material facts which conclusively confirm that global climate engineering has long since been deployed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s